What is better xtal? Bapho or Yashiro dad?

Just asking what is better addgear xtal for meele class..

 

Imo;
Bapho benefits Katana the most because it has both +6% Unsheathe Attack and +6% SRD (also good for unsheathe DW, but who goes for unsheathe DW nowadays lol). It is also good for Halberd, it gives +6% SRD and LRD which keeps balance to DT's damage.

Yashiro is mostly good for DW and Knucle. The ASPD it gives is sort of a bonus to them.

But then again, this is just my opinion

 

Bapho is amazing because of the short range damage boost as it is basically a flat 6% boost to DPS which is better than say 6% atk for anything within the range and that is pretty significant. It's just stupid good on katana with the unsheath on top of it

 

what if for ths? I want to test damage yashiro dad xtal to ths, but I don't have any budget to buy another add gear

 

Ths with Meteor, Yashiro Dad
Ths with Enchant, Bapho